吃中药要小心了-同仁堂牛黄解毒片含有巨量有害毒素

little2sheep

英国药品局：同仁堂牛黄解毒片含有巨量有害毒素
阿思达克通讯社8月21日讯 英国药品及保健品管理署(MHRA)周一在官网上发布了一则中药警告，称这些中药含有巨量的有害毒素，包括铅、水银以及砷，其中一款产品厂商是国内的同仁堂(600085.SH)。

此次被警告的产品有北京同仁堂的牛黄解毒片、保灵堂的白凤丸以及恒隆昌的发宝。这几款产品都未被授权可以进入英国市场，但调查人员还是在市场中发现这些药物。

其中的白凤丸之前就在香港被召回，原因是铅的含量是正常含量的两倍。而发宝内所含的水银成分是标准的11倍。据瑞典国家食品管理局称，他们发现北京同仁堂生产的牛黄解毒片中含有巨量的砷。

什么是砷

砷是一种以有毒而著名的类金属，并有许多的同素异形体。砷的氧化物叫做砒霜，有剧毒。是铜精炼的副产品。

bullpower

use poison to attack poison is the essence of traditional chinese medicine.

little2sheep

同仁堂回应牛黄解毒片含毒：中外标准不一导致

　　搜狐财经讯 英国药品及保健品管理署(MHRA)周一在官网上发布了一则中药警告，称这些中药含有巨量的有害毒素，包括铅、水银以及砷，此次被警告的产品有北京同仁堂的牛黄解毒片。

　　搜狐财经电话连线北京同仁堂科技发展股份有限公司的产品工作人员，该工作人员说，我们已经关注到这条消息，但是觉得此消息比较片面，我们的牛黄解毒片是经过国家规定生产的，经过国家安全的标准；还有就是两国的用药标准不一样。

　　谈到此种有害毒素是否影响到人体健康时，该工作人员表示，因为中药和西药是不一样的，中药讲究一个配伍，各种有毒素的药物配合在一起会起到一定的中和，毒素也会消除。

　　数月前，同仁堂多款产品曝出汞超标和朱砂成分超标，北京同仁堂24日发表声明称：北京同仁堂公司生产的牛黄千金散、小儿至宝丸，严格按照国家药品标准加工、生产和销售，不存在朱砂超标问题，患者遵医嘱按照药品使用说明书服用是安全有效的。此声明被指避重就轻.

little2sheep

bullpower 发表于 2013-8-21 11:40
use poison to attack poison is the essence of traditional chinese medicine.

以毒攻毒有什么科学依据？
从生物学的观点来看，水银可与体内器官蛋白结合，破坏或降低体内器官的功能，造成对体内器官不可逆转的伤害。

bullpower

little2sheep 发表于 2013-8-21 10:49
以毒攻毒有什么科学依据？
从生物学的观点来看，水银可与体内器官蛋白结合，破坏或降低体内器官的功能， ...

i'm just saying a fact.

Modern science cannot explain anything/everything in the universe.

sonicwithtails

I believe one does not even need modern science to understand 以毒攻毒 is BS. We have something else that is called common sense.

Now just for the fun of it, let's suppose 以毒攻毒 is not BS. Then i argue Chinese people already have the purest bodies in the world and therefore do not need any extra medicine. You see, they already breathe in poisonous air and eat poisonous foods everyday -- that's plenty of free treatment. Why pay more?

bullpower

sonicwithtails 发表于 2013-8-21 11:24
I believe one does not even need modern science to understand 以毒攻毒 is BS. We have something else ...

such a narrow minded statement.

nobody would ask you to take poisonous matters blindly, definitely not Chinese traditional medicine.
Just like you don't take western medicine blindly, as simple as that.

The overdose of HG Ar(or AS??) might be a result of human errors or flaws in manufacturing.


In fact vaccination is a perfect example of yi du gong du.

sonicwithtails

bullpower 发表于 2013-8-21 13:59
such a narrow minded statement.

nobody would ask you to take poisonous matters blindly, definitel ...

If I do not have flu but I take a flu vaccination, does this vaccination poison me? if vaccine alone does not poison me, then why do I define it as poison?

I am aware there is an ongoing debate on vaccines and some people claim they are poisonous. But some others claim they are not...I believe you belong to the former group.

I define poison as common sense poison, as something that harms you when you take it alone.

I guess my definition is just wrong.

BTW before I traveled to Africa, doctors recommended that I took at least 7 extra vaccines. in your definition, they just asked me to get 7 shots of poisons.

bullpower

sonicwithtails 发表于 2013-8-21 13:17
If I do not have flu but I take a flu vaccination, does this vaccination poison me? if vaccine alo ...

how do you know? Don't u remember you need to answer a long list of questions before flu vaccination?

It's all up to the doze/volumn you take and individual human body, right?

Human body is not 0 tolerant/100% vulnerable. It can flush things out.

sonicwithtails

bullpower 发表于 2013-8-21 14:28
how do you know? Don't u remember you need to answer a long list of questions before flu vaccinati ...

I think this argument has sound logic and covers something I never cared to think about before. Thanks. Good education for me.