Form or Function?

IntoTheWind

Form or Function?

型式与功能是辩证的逻辑关系, 任何强调其中之一, 而忽视另一个的思想都是严重错误的.

首先型式决定功能, 型式的大骨架是物理力学与人体生理结构共同决定的, 很少有差别. 不同的型式, 产生不同的功能. 错误的形式只能产生错误的功能.

这一点也决定了, 学习必然是从学习型式开始.

功能决定型式, 是说根据想要的不同功能, 来选择相应的型式, 而不是否认型式对功能的决定性作用.

其次正确的型式不是唯一的. 一些没那么重要的次要细节, 衍生出了各种风格的型式.

最后要防止盲目追求型式的倾向. 因为型式的致命重要性, 容易导致大家在苦命追求型式的同时, 却忘掉了型式的本来目的 - 功能.

KuoiGuaBoarder

真理就是大白话， 说多了人瞌睡，大侠要不停地讲个笑话，不然看不下去

firehwak2018

不是form is determined by function 么？

luvski

KuoiGuaBoarder 发表于 2014-4-21 11:47
真理就是大白话， 说多了人瞌睡，大侠要不停地讲个笑话，不然看不下去

入风大侠的这个帖子我倒是看懂了， 也没打瞌睡。

bullpower

I don't think all of the above understand what "form is determined by function" truly means
You guys just take one sentence out of its whole context and judge it.

Please take a lesson.

KuoiGuaBoarder

bullpower 发表于 2014-4-21 12:26
I don't think all of the above understand what "form is determined by function" truly means
You guys ...

牛哥眼真毒，我就是一知半解，牛哥啥时候开个讲坛呗

bullpower

I don't know your context, as all I can see is your whole post:
-------------------------------------------------------
Form or Function?

型式与功能是辩证的逻辑关系, 任何强调其中之一, 而忽视另一个的思想都是严重错误的.

首先型式决定功能, 型式的大骨架是物理力学与人体生理结构共同决定的, 很少有差别. 不同的型式, 产生不同的功能. 错误的形式只能产生错误的功能.

这一点也决定了, 学习必然是从学习型式开始.

功能决定型式, 是说根据想要的不同功能, 来选择相应的型式, 而不是否认型式对功能的决定性作用.

其次正确的型式不是唯一的. 一些没那么重要的次要细节, 衍生出了各种风格的型式.

最后要防止盲目追求型式的倾向. 因为型式的致命重要性, 容易导致大家在苦命追求型式的同时, 却忘掉了型式的本来目的 - 功能.
-------------------------------------------
And this is wrong.

If you teach your students form, they won't understand and won't be convinced.
they will struggle when they try to follow your form against their original form.

bullpower

And there is no "产生错误的功能",
I think you are talking about result instead of function.

CSIA defines function clearly in the book
All terrain, any conditions..free to choose line and speed ... with economy of effort.

bullpower

one example is how you would teach a drill "facing downhill".
Can you explain how you would teach?

firehwak2018

又回到了两种教学理念的问题上~~~